Autonomy is a matter of interest not only for academics, but equally for practitioners involved
in negotiations about institutional design (politicians, civil
servants, their advisors and third party facilitators from international
organizations). Bearing this in mind, the research conducted for this
project also has a decidedly practical purpose, i.e. to make precisely
such people aware of the wealth of options provided by existing autonomy
arrangements. Even though it is not possible to transplant one
arrangement in its entirety from one context to another, such awareness
may facilitate the work of practitioners because it prevents them from
having to re-invent every single aspect of the wheel. This has two main
implications for our research. First, in order to demonstrate the real
wealth of options at hand, we do not limit ourselves to the analysis of
the widely acclaimed standard cases, but also cover lesser-known and so
far understudied arrangements of autonomy. Secondly, the practical
approach compels us to focus on information that is really useful for
practitioners and to present it in a user-friendly manner.
characteristic of research within this project is its effort to link
insights gained by previous studies from different academic disciplines.
In concrete terms, we aim in our analysis to bridge comparative politics and comparative constitutional law.
The project team is well suited for such an endeavor because it is
composed of experienced researchers from both disciplines. Moreover,
external experts contributing case studies to the webpage are required
to equally consider both law and political science aspects of the
respective autonomy arrangements.
Furthermore, our research is inspired by the aim to bridge studies on territorial and non-territorial autonomy.
While territorial arrangements are on a global scale clearly more
numerous and better covered by academic analysis, there has been since
the 1990s a trend towards very diverse non-territorial arrangements. The
fact that our research also scrutinizes and presents numerous cases of
this latter form of autonomy constitutes an important added value. This
puts people interested in the webpage in a position to keep track of the
enormous variety, which autonomy arrangements stand for today.
Mohawk community's 'marry out, get out' law ruled unconstitutional by Quebec court
30 April 2018 (Montreal, Canada)
Quebec Superior Court declared discriminatory and unconstitutional a long-standing rule of the Mohawk Council of Kahnawake reserve, according to which Mohawk people who marry non-natives must leave the community. The judgment establishes limits on native autonomy. The Mohawk Council defends the so-called "Marry Out, Get Out" law as a way of safeguarding Mohawk land and culture. However, the Court held that the Mohawk Council failed to demonstrate how its membership law was helping protect the community's culture or resources, and concluded that the law violated the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms on the basis of family status and civil status. Read more...
International Seminar on Asymmetry in Decentralised Systems
22-23 March 2018, Padang (Indonesia)
The international seminar and expert meeting on "Asymmetry in Decentralised Systems – Balancing Regional Diversity with National Harmony" brought together scholars and practitioners from Australia, Germany, Indonesia, Italy, Philippines, South Africa and Switzerland. Our project team was represented by Sergiu Constantin (Institute for Minority Rights, Eurac Research) and Tove Malloy (European Centre for Minority Issues). The event was organized by Max Plank Foundation and Max Plank Institute (Germany), Andalas University (Indonesia) and Curtin University (Australia).
Call for Applications: Summer School on Human Rights, Minorities and Diversity Governance - Focus 2018: Power Sharing in Divided Societies
1 March 2018, Bolzano/Bozen (Italy)
The 2018 Summer School explores the theme of "Power Sharing in Divided Societies" by examining the challenge of complex diversity, through theoretical and empirical perspectives from Europe, Middle East, Southeast Asia and South America. In seminars and workshops led by international experts, participants will critically engage with topics including international minority protection instruments, constitutional design in divided societies, religious and cultural diversity, and borders and cross-border cooperation. The Summer School will take place in the period 9 - 20 July 2018 and the deadline for
application is 30 April 2018. Scholarships are available. Read more...
French President rejects key Corsica autonomy demands
7 February 2018, Ajaccio (France)
While visiting Corsica, president Macron offered to add a special mention of the island into the French Constitution but ruled out giving the Corsican language an official status and rejected other demands of the nationalist parties. In December 2017, a coalition of nationalist parties won 41 of the 63 seats in Corsica's regional assembly. The nationalists claim inter alia autonomy and a special status for the island in the French Constitution, official status for Corsican language alongside French and amnesty for Corsicans jailed for pro-independence violence. Read more....
Hungarians in Romania Renew Call for Autonomy
9 January 2018, Cluj-Napoca/Kolozsvár (Romania)
The three parties of Hungarian minority in Romania signed a joint resolution on autonomy concepts. They claim regional autonomy for Szeklerland (a historical region with Hungarian majority population), "special administrative status" for Partium (a historical region with a significant Hungarian population), administrative autonomy for municipalities with Hungarian majority population and cultural autonomy for all Hungarians living in Romania. Most ethnic Hungarians of Romania live in Transylvania, which became part of Romania after the First World War. Read more...
Backlash against independence bids of Iraqi Kurdistan and Catalonia
25-27 October 2017, Erbil (Iraq) and Barcelona (Spain)
A referendum on independence was held in Iraqi Kurdistan on 25 September 2017 despite Iraq's Supreme Court order to suspend the vote after the Iraqi parliament had declared it unconstitutional. On 1 October 2017, Catalonia held its own independence referendum although the Spanish Constitutional Court suspended the Catalan referendum law. Both referendums were met with strong domestic and international criticism. In mid-October, Iraqi troops attacked Kurdish security forces and captured several key disputed areas. On 25 October, Iraqi Kurdistan decided to "freeze" the referendum result and start a dialogue with Baghdad. On 27 October, the Catalan parliament unilaterally declared independence from Spain. Madrid suspended the autonomy of Catalonia, dissolved the Catalan parliament and called for regional elections on 21 December. Read more about the situation in Catalonia and Iraqi Kurdistan.
Dawn Walsh, Territorial Self-Government as a Conflict Management Tool, Palgrave Macmillan, 2018
This book provides an in-depth narrative of the difficulties facing Territorial Self-Government institutions across Northern Ireland, Bosnia, the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, Moldova, and Iraq. It brings together analyses of both prominent and lesser known cases to provide a broad overview of how Territorial Self-Government operates as a conflict management tool in different contexts. Drawing on lessons from these five cases, the author demonstrates the importance of designing and implementing international guarantees to self-government and the associated difficulties. Read more...
Dejan Stjepanović, Multiethnic Regionalisms in Southeastern Europe: Statehood Alternatives, Comparative Territorial Politics Series, Palgrave, 2017
This book is based on a comparative study of regionalisms in Croatia's regions of Dalmatia and Istria as well as Serbia's Vojvodina. The monograph's main focus is on regionalist political party strategies since 1990, and within that, each case study considers history and historiography, inter-group relations, economics, and region-building. The analysis demonstrates that many of the common assumptions about the causal determinants of territorial autonomy projects and outcomes, as well as about a teleological and unidirectional path from regionalism to nationalism, do not stand up to scrutiny. Read more...
Kimana Zulueta-Fülscher, Asanga Welikala, "Substate Constitutions in Fragile and Conflict-affected Settings", International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance, Policy Paper No. 15, 2017
Substate constitutions are understood as written legal instruments that limit and structure political power at the substate level, with legal supremacy regarding other substate laws. This Policy Paper examines substate constitutions in fragile and conflict-affected settings—in both federal and unitary (or hybrid) states—adopted after the end of the Cold War starting in 1991. It aims to fill a significant gap in the policy and academic literature and it covers 10 countries: Bosnia and Herzegovina, Comoros, Ethiopia, Indonesia, Papua New Guinea, Russia, Somalia, South Africa, South Sudan and Sudan. Read more...
Journal of Autonomy and Security Studies, Volume 1, Issue 1, 2017
The Journal of Autonomy and Security Studies (JASS) is a peer-reviewed, open access e-journal published by the Åland Islands Peace Institute. The journal addresses its overarching theme of peace and security from the perspectives of autonomy, demilitarization, and minority protection. Each issue of JASS will include scholarly articles that in some way deal with the subjects mentioned above. JASS issues may also include other types of material such as project notes, book reviews, and information on pending conferences. JASS is published twice a year – in May and in November. Read more...
Roberto Toniatti, Jens Woelk (eds.), Regional Autonomy, Cultural Diversity and Differentiated Territorial Government. The Case of Tibet – Chinese and Comparative Perspectives, Routledge, 2017
This edited volume assesses the current state of the international theory and practice of autonomy in order to pursue the possibility of regional self-government in Tibet. Examining the Chinese framework of regional self-government, along with key international cases of autonomy in Europe, North America and Asia, the volume offers a comprehensive context for the consideration of both Tibetan demands and Chinese worries. Their insights will be invaluable to academics, practitioners, diplomats, civil servants, government representatives, international organisations and NGOs interested in the theory and practice of autonomy, as well as those concerned with the future of Tibet. Read more...
Allison McCulloch, John McGarry (eds.), Power Sharing: Empirical and Normative Challenges, Routledge, 2017
This edited volume aims to enhance our understanding of the utility of power-sharing in deeply divided places by subjecting power-sharing theory and practice to empirical and normative analysis and critique. This text will be of interest to students, scholars and practitioners of power-sharing, ethnic politics, democracy and democratization, peace-building, comparative constitutional design, and more broadly Comparative Politics, International Relations and Constitutional and Comparative Law. Read more...
(ed.), Non-territorial Autonomy in Divided Societies. Comparative Perspectives,
This volume aims
to fill a gap in the academic literature on non-territorial autonomy (NTA) by
offering a comparative assessment of the significance of this political
institutional device. Developed theoretically by Karl Renner in the early
twentieth century as a mechanism for responding to demands for self-government
from dispersed minorities within the Austro-Hungarian Empire, NTA had earlier
roots in the Ottoman Empire, and later formed the basis for constitutional
experiments in Estonia, in Belgium, and in states with sizeable but dispersed
minorities. Read more...